Skip to content
Search
Home
Holiday Specials
Samplers with Free Shipping
All Products
All Products
Cheeses
Butcher's Secret Stash
Condiments
Drinks
Goose Gear
Larder Meats
Pickles
Salumi
Sampler Packs with Free Shipping
Sausages
Seafood
Sliced Deli Meats
Smoked Meats
Snacks
Tray Packs
Whole Muscle
FAQ + Contact
Gift Cards
Account
Site navigation
Search
Search
Cart
Menu
Site navigation
Home
Holiday Specials
Samplers with Free Shipping
All Products
All Products
Cheeses
Butcher's Secret Stash
Condiments
Drinks
Goose Gear
Larder Meats
Pickles
Salumi
Sampler Packs with Free Shipping
Sausages
Seafood
Sliced Deli Meats
Smoked Meats
Snacks
Tray Packs
Whole Muscle
FAQ + Contact
Gift Cards
Account
Item added to cart.
View cart and check out
.
Close
Close
free shipping on any $75+
Close
Condiments
Sort by
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sweet Hot Mustard
Regular price
$12
Sale price
$8.95
Sale
View
Pickled Mustard Seeds
Regular price
$12
Sale price
$8.95
Sale
View
White Truffle Mustard
Regular price
$12
Sale price
$8.95
Sale
View
Zaatar Spread: regular or hot
Regular price
$13
Sale price
$12.50
Sale
View
Zaatar Spice: regular or hot
Regular price
$8
Sale price
$7.50
Sale
View
Membrillo Quince Paste
Regular price
$12
Sale price
$9.75
Sale
View
Cherry Butter
Regular price
$11
Sale price
$8.95
Sale
View
Pommery Honey Moutarde
Regular price
$13
Sale price
$11.95
Sale
View
Hot Toddy Apple Butter
Regular price
$10
Sale price
$8.50
Sale
View
Batch No 2 Ballpark Yellow Mustard
Sold Out
Sale
View
St. Elmo Remoulade
Regular price
$8
Sale price
$7.50
Sale
View
St. Elmo Truffle Dijonnaise
Regular price
$8
Sale price
$7.50
Sale
View
St. Elmo Root Beer Glaze
Regular price
$8
Sale price
$7.50
Sale
View
Absinthe Orange Deliciousness: Good Food Award Finalist
Regular price
$6
Sale price
$5.75
Sale
View
Cherry Fig Mostarda: Good Food Award Winner
Sold Out
Sale
View
Pueblo Chile Peach Deliciousness
Sold Out
Sale
View
Hardwood Honey on the Comb: Small
Sold Out
Sale
View
Organic Savory Seeds: Curry
Regular price
$5
Sale price
$2.95
Sale
View
Organic Savory Seeds: Sea Salt
Regular price
$5
Sale price
$2.95
Sale
View
House Olive Salad
Regular price
$9.95
Sale price
$7.95
Sale
View
←
1
2
3
4
5
→
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.
Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device